Currently, the POS infrastructure for ZARA is outdated and
putting the company at risk. Xan Salgado Badas and Bruno Sanchez Ocampo are at
a turning point of discussion and a decision needs to be made. Salgado Badas
believes that their current system needs to be updated to meet their current
operational needs while Sanchez adamantly opposes. Although, this may be the
case currently, each IT manager has changed his opinion several times.
Regardless, the DOS software that is installed is no longer supported by
Microsoft. This can eventually lead to issue, but operations currently run with
no issue. Yet, the company is at serious risk as new technologies continue to
emerge.
Zara is at inherent risk because of the limited capabilities
of their current DOS system and how dated the software is. This has become
apparent through operations; significant inefficiencies are created through
time wasted in the system running and going through tasks. Newer age technology
allows employees to maneuver through the system real time to complete tasks
such as inventory availability lookup. Therefore, their dated technology will
eventually create a competitive advantage for Zara’s competitors and induce
loss in profits. An IT solution needs to be implemented in order for all
players in Zara’s supply chain to enjoy faster product turnover and strengthen
relationships.
Assessment
Zara continues to experience expansion on a domestic level
and would like to enjoy growth internationally. Zara’s core competencies depict
an organization that gets the latest fashion products to its consumers fast. It
currently lacks a large international presence but believes it can be very
effective in such markets. Typically, an IT system would be able to track movement
of its many products instantaneously, but because of its lack of online sales
it has neglected to implement such a system. When a new store is opened little
assistance from IT professional is needed. By simply inserting a floppy disk
into a terminal drive the new computer has the required applications installed.
Next to no maintenance was necessary if basic system error occurred. This is
definitely a major advantage. Alternatively, if a serious issue occurred an
entirely new software package would need to be installed. Regardless, minimal
IT support is needed for new stores and although dated, existing systems can
support expansion.
In conclusion, several major questions need to be addressed
before a decision can be comfortably made. If a new IT system is implemented
how easily can Zara continue with its daily operations with minimal
disruptions? Also, will the large monetary investment needed be worth the added
and increased functionality? Will the new infrastructure allow Zara to
continuous its expansion efforts both domestically and abroad?
Necessary Alternatives
The first and most obvious alternative is to do nothing and
leave are current infrastructure in place. Zero initial investment would be
incurred and in effect next to no risk would be had from a financial
standpoint. Although, in doing nothing there is risk because it creates
inefficiencies throughout the company. Our technology would in essence “lag”
and our immediate competitors may enjoy a competitive advantage. Our current
employees would not need training on new IT platforms, but we would not have
tech based efficiency gains.
The second option includes total and complete upgrade to our
IT infrastructure which includes our POS terminals. We would utilize Linux,
Unix, or Windows as one of our new operating systems. By incorporating a new
system we could entirely remove the need for installation through floppy disk
because this could be accomplished through the internet. The internet also
allows stores to connect to Wi-Fi, which makes it easier to communicate in all
areas of the supply chain and execute returns on a much faster basis. Many
benefits occur through a new IT system, yet the investment needed is also quite
large. Some 15k hours of labor would be needed to convert the system at a rate
of approximately 450 euros, this becomes a staggering figure. Training would
also be a costly endeavor coming to about 2,000 euros per day per store. Almost
a week would be needed at this rate to install the new machines and train
employees. Allow stark the functionality
obtained through the update is almost incalculable. Returns become much easy,
stock is easier to track and sales information becomes available
instantaneously.
Recommendation
Ultimately, although the monetary investment may be large we
need to mitigate our IT infrastructure to a new OS system. The added
functionality which we could gain over the long term far outweighs initial
costs. We would have internet and WI-FI in every store which allows for easier
communication. The initial setup of stores would be streamlined and done over
the web rather than being reliant on cumbersome floppy disks. Lastly, inventory
and returns can be tracked on a much more intelligent level. All of these
reasons play major roles in my decision to suggest change. If we continue down
are current path we are putting ourselves at risk from competitors and are not
taking advantage of technological advances.
Reflection/Review of Presentation (2/27)
Ladies and Gentleman of the board after reviewing
yesterday’s presentation, allow well done, several adjustments could have been
to make our decision easier. I believe a more in depth analysis of future
expansion and the role a new infrastructure plays in this process should have
been provided. It would have allowed us to determine whether success in
international markets is directly correlated to an updated IT system or not. In
addition, it may have been helpful to see actual figures and units of measure
associated with each alternative.
The associates utilized an approach that provided a biased
position rather than complete oversight of the situation. They tried their best
to influence the C-Level managers towards choosing a complete full scale
upgrade from existing system to that of Linux operating system. Although, I
completely agree with their assumptions I believe it is important to highlight
the point that this could hurt the company over the long term. By providing
mostly benefits to the upgrade we were partly blind to the advantages
associated with our historically successful system.
Although, some
improvements could have been made to the presentation, I am confident in
suggesting the implementation of new and an up to date IT system. This will
provide stability to our expansion and allow us to better monitor our progress.
We have achieved great growth, netting nearly 380 million in 2001 and expanding
are foothold worldwide to 1,558 locations. Integrating a new IT system will
allow us to maintain such expansion and reach even greater heights.