Issue/Underlying Problem
As Marcus Kingo’s business “1-888-JUNK-VAN grew, he began to
encounter issues that would prevent further expansion. His company lacked an
IT-system and he desperately needed to introduce a cost effective solution
immediately. “1-888-JUNK-VAN” had endured such fast growth that the
implementation of an IT-System was crucial because they were currently
mishandling information which was preventing them from acquiring new customers. This resulted in stalled market growth, harmed current customer relations, and prevented C-Level managers from focusing on managerial functions.
On countless occasions, data clerks and drivers were
inputting incorrect or insufficient data into their current IT system which harmed employee morale on many levels. Another significant obstacle was their inability to
have multiple working spreadsheets. This made having multiple clerks booking
jobs and maintaining accurate accounts almost impossible. What made things
worse was the data clerk whom was to upload the day’s final product into the
database often uploaded a dated or inaccurate spreadsheet. This left Marcus the
daunting task the following day of sorting through and fixing the broken and in
turn preventing new jobs from being booked.
Ultimately, for “1-888-JUNK-VAN”, implementing a cost
effective IT infrastructure is absolutely vital. Aspirations of incorporating
franchises and capitalizing on large predicted industry growth has left Marcus
desperate. The necessary IT tools would make Marcus’s position as CEO easier,
and allow him to focus his efforts on expansion rather than fixing pending issues. Having
previously lacked any brick and mortar office location, which kept costs low,
Marcus Kingo has several options to consider if he wants to keep with growth.
Discussion of Alternatives
1. One of Marcus’s potential solutions to his IT dilemma is the implementation of Microsoft Access Database. This would be an affordable solution that Kingo could complete by himself over the course of several weeks. The license fee per computer is approximately $179. Additionally, if King deemed it necessary, it could be installed so that it could be remotely accessed. This would require diligent study on Kingo's Part, or require outside consultants to assist. Regardless, by utilizing MS Database there would be no need for a data clerk to upload the spreadsheet at the end of the day and this appears to be the most cost effective solution.
1. One of Marcus’s potential solutions to his IT dilemma is the implementation of Microsoft Access Database. This would be an affordable solution that Kingo could complete by himself over the course of several weeks. The license fee per computer is approximately $179. Additionally, if King deemed it necessary, it could be installed so that it could be remotely accessed. This would require diligent study on Kingo's Part, or require outside consultants to assist. Regardless, by utilizing MS Database there would be no need for a data clerk to upload the spreadsheet at the end of the day and this appears to be the most cost effective solution.
2. Customized Application is another option which Marcus has considered. This could potentially be an excellent alternative considering the specification included yet several issues may arise. First, by having someone custom build a system, they don’t fully understand the needs of the company and may create something that is not beneficial. Second, the overall cost of such an endeavor may far outweigh the benefits. With a custom system, there would also be a need to hire additional IT professionals to continuously update and maintain the infrastructure.
3. Another feasible option is that of Google Documents which is low cost and allows for the most flexibility for the end user. Several employees can simultaneously work on the same file and it can be exchanged instantly. Additionally, there are no fees endured from licensing or the purchase of this IT method. This cloud computing option does offer some risk. For starters, if Google Docs stops offering this product all of “1-888-JUNK-VAN’s” files would need to be immediately moved or could be lost for that matter. Another issue that arises is that Google Docs currently does not offer any type of customer support. These fees are difficult to estimate because existing employee IT knowledge is unpredictable.
4. Platform as a Service is another interesting yet similar option to that of Google Documents. It is based on a cloud computing model but offers additional flexibility in that users can create their own applications. This alternative is also more of an investment than that of Google Docs costing approximately $300-$600 per month and almost $200 per month in customer service and or application customization. This like Google Docs is a feasible option despite the cost associated with it. Ultimately, Marcus needs to consider whether or not he will be able to handle the IT maintenance required. If the task seems too daunting, additional investment would be necessary to hire IT professionals.
5. The fifth and final option being considered today is that of Enterprise Resource Planning System. This alternative provides the most variety in tools offered. With the purchase of the system other business functions are acquired such as purchasing and sales programs. Although helpful, the cost being $2500 per user per year does not make sense for a still relatively small company like “1-888-JUNK-VAN”. Some advantages are that ERP system does allow several users the ability to remotely access files and easily exchange and share information. Ultimately, this system does offer some advantages but with its high costs it may not necessarily be a perfect fit for the company.
Recommendation
In conclusion, I would recommend “1-888-JUNK-VAN” upgrade from their current IT platform to Google Documents. The implementation of this system will allow for the greatest flexibility, meet the current needs of the company and be the most cost-effective. By using Google Docs, “1-888-JUNK-VAN” employees can work on several documents at once and even remote access files from their homes. This will help Marcus remain true with his company’s initial principals of remaining completely a non-brick and mortar business. Ultimately, by utilizing Google Docs, a large monetary investment is not necessary and the transition between systems should be fairly simple and not require outside help. To provide further prediction, I believe that if Google Docs does not meet the needs of the company, Marcus can easily adapt another one of the suggested solutions without taking a large financial hit.
Reflection/Review of Presentation (2/20/13)
Ladies and Gentleman of the board after reviewing yesterday's presentation, allow well done, several adjustments could have been made to make our decision easier. First and foremost, I believe a more in depth analysis of each option could have been presented. There appeared to be holes in some of the lines of reasoning which led us to question the effectiveness of such an alternative. Regardless, enough information was given and we were able to confidently move forward with one of the IT solutions. As described, although costly, I believe utilizing a custom application with significant oversight can be the most effective tool for our future success.
No comments:
Post a Comment