Friday, April 19, 2013

Pandora


Sir,
                As you are aware, Pandora is at a turning point within its business life cycle and several issues need be to immediately addressed. More specifically the underlying problem; how does Pandora turn a profit from revenue and how do they maintain and attract customers? Currently, Pandora’s overall mission is being swayed by its many venture capitalists each with their own motives. Tim Westergren started the company with a dream and is trying his best to maintain it. Unfortunately, management believes that if they continue down this path by years end there will be zero cash on hand. Several core issues plague Pandora but with precise action we believe we can eradicate any long lasting negative effects.
            
             To begin, we believe Pandora does not have the personnel needed to manage and guide a company in the media industry. We have found that in general they lack the professional experience needed and in turn this hinders their ability to properly manage. Tim Westergren acknowledges this predicament and even suggests that he was not properly qualified nor had a desire to guide Pandora and become the CEO.  Unfortunately, this was a common thread throughout many of the leadership roles. Individuals lacked experience or in general weren’t happy and didn’t feel comfortable with their job descriptions. Secondly, Pandora was not meeting customer demands and lacked integral advertising to attract and maintain customer base. Other listening mediums had perfected this area and Pandora was losing market share to power hungry competitors. Business’s in general enjoy growth and thrive through the addition of new clients in part from a strategic marketing plan.

 Another conjoining issue or desire was to be the most effective company at helping consumers find the music they were looking for.  Joe Kennedy, recently hired CEO (2004) recognizes this problem and attempts to address it with direct to consumer internet radio service.  This gave birth to Pandora Radio which contributed to a successful future. Regardless, meeting the needs of their consumers through desired music genres was paramount. Moving forward, several issues plagued Pandora and we as consultants in the ensuing paragraphs plan to provide a series of effective alternatives and solutions.

In an attempt to establish a loyal and continuously growing customer base, Pandora needs to establish some guidelines in how they will advertise and market to new consumers. This will play a crucial role in future probability and expand market share. In 2007, revenues were approximately .69 cents per hour per listener. This is a competitive rate if they are able to maintain current users, but since no money was being spent on advertising, margins became stagnant and effected growth. Through a established marketing strategy Pandora should be able to differentiate themselves, continue to provide a free services, and attract new customers with additional media platforms such as cell phones and tablets.

Several different options surface when discussing the main issues surrounding Pandora’s future. The first option is do nothing and proceed as if no problems need to be addressed. This typically is the most attractive alternative, because no investment cost is necessary and there is no loss in production from adhering to new missions or infrastructure. In contrast, Pandora doing nothing will continue to see only moderate profits and sorely under achieve growth in customer base.  Our analysis concludes that this option should not be pursued.

The second alternative is to transition to a premium subscription based model. This option fuels profits and creates a better product for the end user. It is a strictly ad free model that provided a reasonable cost structure establishes a loyal customer base through new features such as better song selection and as mentioned no ads. We feel that existing users who utilize the free option should continue to enjoy our product, but will be capped and restricted on a monthly basis to a certain predetermined threshold. In contrast, having to pay for our service may deter some users and push them to our competitors which still offer it for free.

The third option involves a combination of a subscription ad free based model and the current infrastructure flushed with additional advertisements. No real value is added to the end consumer in terms of the product, meaning no new perks or options are provided. Yet, the service remaining free is an enticing avenue AND more revenue is generated through advertising from companies who want their brand to receive more exposure. It allows advertisers to specifically target certain demographics which can lead to commission fees if users make purchases on linked websites. In addition, the amount of ads can be reduced if users answer questions about music preferences. We believe this is the most attractive of alternatives because it generates more revenue for you (Pandora) and keeps the service free.

Ultimately, upon further analysis of the three presented options, I believe that option three should be pursued. As described this alternative involves utilizing a subscription ad free model and the current free service with additional ads. In turn this will help maintain current customer base, create new revenues, and attract and obtain new market share. Attempting to achieve economies of scales and remaining true with Westergren’s dreams will create the most value for its shareholders and is least detrimental to everyday operations. By establishing a new strategy and employing personnel with the proper experience Pandora can continue to better their service and remain competitive.

Some other key ingredients to Pandora’s success will be to remain differentiated and adapt to a changing environment and embracing new technologies. Focusing on client needs by offering premier services will allow an atmosphere where a consumer’s view of advertisements is merely an afterthought because they are receiving an unbelievable product. By achieving economies of scale solid profits can be received which keeps investors satisfied with new missions and directions of the business. In conclusion, it is logical to suggest that in a service type business, advertising and market is crucial but maintaining and nurturing client desires and image is second to none.


Reflection

Sir,
I hope this message finds you well. As per our discussion/presentation yesterday regarding Pandora and its future I would like to bring forth several conclusions to assist in your decision. Upon further analysis, I believe what our consultants have suggested makes sense and should be pursued based upon our business position. Remaining within the parameters of our goals and business strategies it would be prudent on our part to at least consider their recommendations. Below I’ll recap what was discussed and highlight the important details.

As suggested, remaining differentiated by offering and maintaining a free service utilizing targeted marketing is above all else vital. In addition to this free service, offering a subscription service that is ad-free is enticing and does meet the needs of a specific demographic. With this two-tiered approach being pursued, Pandora can begin the realignment of its mission of focusing on scale and attracting new customers through new technologies.

The above listed strategies are the overall direction in which the consultants and I believe Pandora should move. In order to achieve these missions, the consultants recommended several actions each with a specific purpose. Introducing and providing a Mobile Application offered both on Apple and Android products allows us to attract new customers and bring in additional revenue. This in the eyes of the consultants is cutting/leading edge technology, which any good development team will create in the near future. Restructuring our budget to focus on the production and updating of this mobile application should be initiated and other frivolous spending should be reduced.

In addition to our new focus on technologies, adapting a two-tiered approach which incorporates subscription based offerings will lead to greater revenues. This should be immediately adapted because as discussed profit margins at year end will fall short of expectations. Regardless of the subscription or offering that a customer chooses, it had been suggested that Pandora include some audio advertising for additional revenue. This can be as small as a 15 second clip, or as in depth as an interactive game or advertisement. Of course, consumers who opt for the premier subscription package will avoid this all together.

As you have witnessed, the consultants did an excellent job of dissecting the many issues that concern Pandora. There recommended action should not be taken lightly and we should immediately implement these ideas where we can and budget accordingly.

Thank you for your time and consideration and please contact me with any further issues.

Monday, April 15, 2013

Harrah's


Sir,
As you are aware, Harrah’s has set the precedent in creating value for its shareholders and developing an underlying unified brand approach. Previously, casino management teams relied heavily on a theory which segregated gambling entities in an everyman for themselves approach.  This prehistoric strategy has been refuted by Harrah’s new brand approach which allows various casinos to operate in an integrated manner.  Harrah’s was able to accomplish this company wide mission by integrating a customized IT system to monitor consumer behavior and activity. In turn, sophisticated and targeted marketing campaigns ensued which created increased revenue for stakeholders. Newly implemented IT infrastructure called WINet database allowed Harrah’s brand to put emphasis on customer satisfaction and appreciation. It collected countless reams of data and formulated specific player profiles which fueled targeted advertising and eventually bottom line figures.

Ultimately, the issue or problem at hand is how new casinos are being built/developed around the implementation of sophisticated IT systems which fuel growth.  Alternatively, Harrah’s could have continued down a path where data was inputted and tracked manually, which is significantly less effective. As we have observed at Harrah’s an emphasis was placed on obtaining customer information and properly communicating it through all areas of the business. If customers visited a casino on just one occasion, Harrah’s felt confident they would return and be consistent/loyal patrons. What was crucial in this retention was the storage of all data on a real time basis for analysis at a later date. Due diligence was then conducted to categorize and segment customers so they could then be properly marketed too. This was a unique and cutting edge strategy that through profits has proven successful.

The theoretical concepts should be evaluated against the alternatives to properly determine probability of success. This means we should analyze Harrah’s successes and failures regarding its investment in the CRM solution. We have determined that a strong emphasis was placed on its marketing and advertising approach because they valued the retention of customers. For every percentage point increase in returning customers meant nearly $2 million in net profit annually. In addition, incorporating programs such as Total Rewards (Silver/Platinum/Gold) resulted in a 72% IRR and Harrah’s stock price soared. All lines of Harrah’s business flourished and in doing so set the standard for IT infrastructure throughout the gaming industry.

In conclusion I would recommend a system which incorporates a fully integrated CRM solution that utilizes the “Harrah’s perfected” marketing techniques that focuses on customer satisfaction.  As with any business there is always room for improvement. Harrah’s should seek to reduce inefficiencies and create more value for stakeholders. Even more emphasis should be geared towards understanding the mindset of its consumers and evaluating world economic footprint. Significant effort should be focused on several key areas; fluid communication of all Lines of Business, diligent storage and analysis of consumer data, and targeted closed-loop marketing. The necessary professional should be hired to segment consumers by areas of interest; i.e. number of hours gambled, day trip consumers vs. weekend patrons, entertainment eccentric customers.

In creating a presentation for the above mentioned issues and recommendations I would thoroughly explain the reasons why Harrah’s has been successful and the part its CRM solution plays. I would stress the importance of utilizing and creating customer profiles which contribute to effective marketing. The Marketing Workbench has been used to group and segment consumers which allows casino management to understand who is in their establishments. I would provide facts and utilize some visual aid to paint the picture for the audience; 1% retention =$2 million in increased revenue annually, 62% IRR on IT investments. Ultimately, the recommendation and underlying goal are easy for the consultants to identify; retaining customers using technology equates to better bottom line figures.



Reflection

As you are aware Harrah’s as described above has enjoyed multiple years of success through an innovative marketing strategy. One could argue that Harrah’s has done nearly everything perfect and there is no need to make any changes. As we have been lectured on, our hired consultants believe there is still room for improvements. They argue that in order to stay at the forefront of casino gambling we need to become more efficient in the areas we have already excelled. As a cover memo and summary below I will scratch the surface of their recommended action.

The first recommended action or solution involved utilizing a technique called “data mining”. This option has an excellent track record for success and historically speaking has an average rate of return of nearly 62%. It has been the catalyst for much of Harrah’s existing success, and an investment in this area would show as described an excellent return. Several figures were presented to further explain this option; a target demographic of 25,000-50,000 and a consumer rate of approximately $200 results in an excellent return nearly several million in size.

The second recommended action which is apparent in other industries is an online reservation and concierge service. I personally believe this option is one that should be immediately implemented. It is extremely practical with many uses. The airline and hotel industry have revolutionized this service with great success. To utilize this service would easily integrate into our marketing strategy and would bear much fruit. Our IT infrastructure could handle such tasks of booking rooms and sending out confirmation emails because this information is already saved within our data bank.

The third and final option is a complete upgrade to our IT system and infrastructure. The consultants reasoned that the delay between our system populating tasks/orders and them being delivered/conducted is harming operations. An upgrade would decrease this lag time and in turn potentially increase profits. This option is the most costly of the recommended, yet in my eyes should be pursued. To make matters worse, I wasn’t completely convinced with the consultants cost benefit analysis for this option. I believe long term we will see that it is difficult to track the return on this investment.

In conclusion, Harrah’s has endured much success through their strategic marketing strategy. The consultants made some excellent suggestions on how Harrah’s can become more efficient at the things they already do very well. In my opinion, each of the three options would be adopted, although, I would modify recommendation one; concierge and online reservation service. Instead of completing the programing and tasks in house, I would consider outsourcing this because consultants have already experienced the learning curve and can better implement.  Harrah’s management team can direct their efforts towards maintaining a strong marketing strategy.

Thank you for your time and consideration.

Thursday, April 4, 2013

Microsoft Project


Sir,
Before you today, I plan on evaluating in great detail a decision to potentially utilize Microsoft Project for our company. The financial services industry as you know has previously employed a large number of software developers who specialize in developing and working with Microsoft and their different products. This has proven to be an effective method, mainly because of strong relations with clients and it is evident in our large support of business initiatives to foster growth through strong management. Despite out success, it may be prudent on our part to implement Microsoft Office on a full time basis and avoid a heavy reliance on costly developers which currently assist in the management of our projects.

As with any new technology or even the suggestion of it there is often resistance to change. This may be even truer within the financial industry because employees are more focused with streamlining new business initiatives or nurturing client relations; typically they like avoid technology that effects their daily operations. Regardless, it is important for management to interpret new systems to reduce costs and increase productivity of their employees. With this being said, I will explain several benefits that can be had in an attempt for our office to work in a more cohesive manner, foster strong client relations and continue growth through innovation.

An obvious and most apparent benefit to the employment of Microsoft Office is the increase in data being exchanged between our many Microsoft products. Products that can be found in our Microsoft Office Professional version such as Word, Access, Outlook, and Excel will allow for easy integration of Microsoft Project and help streamline data. Yet, it is important to highlight that our software developers who our already Microsoft experts have created a unique project management system for us. Therefore, any enhancements or efficiency that may be created for say an average company would not positively affect us in the same way.

Again, although our attempts are futile in considering the implementation of Microsoft Project for our company because of our existing framework I will provide a cost analysis to further demonstrate this point. On average a single version of Microsoft Project including installation is $600 for the standard and approximately $1200 for the professional version. Compared to some of my previously suggested technology alternatives, the two versions (Professional and Standard) are nearly identical and opting for the cheaper version would suffice. If Merrill Lynch did decide to implement this project management tool we should isolate implementation to one area and because of this I believe a limited number of copies would need to be purchased. It would be prudent on our part to buy copies only for management as the largest benefits can be gained through their use. Entry and lower level employees could continue to use our internal products while upper management could integrate Microsoft Project into their daily work flows/routines.
            
           Therefore, initially implementing this to a single sector such as “Global Markets - Client services” we can minimize investment and test the waters to see if this is a viable option. “Global Markets – Client Services” consists of nearly 300 employees and 25 managers. Therefore, 25 managers x $600(Software) = $15,000. This cost is minimal in comparison to our investment in software developers so testing this product may be a feasible option for argument sake. In addition we should allocate several labor hours to each manager so they can become comfortable using it. The learning curve in my opinion would be sharp in that our managers already have a strong understanding with Microsoft Project type tools. I estimate 3 hours per manager at a rate of $50 per hour, bringing our total to $3750. In total, the estimate cost of implementing Microsoft Project on an isolated basis is $18,750.
              
          Typically speaking when an organization adopts new project management software it creates efficiencies in daily operations and other tedious business practices. This does not necessarily apply to us because of the fact that we already utilize a custom made Microsoft Management program. Yet, to demonstrate the benefits we should assign estimated numbers to project benefits for an outside firm. In one such instance administrative personnel can avoid repeating tasks and potentially remove some of these mundane practices altogether. Another example of increased efficiency can be found in streamlining our notification systems. Rather than having several different programs that do not speak to one another and need to be manually queued, our systems can work together and increase the rate at which notifications and emails are sent. I think it is a safe assumption that implementing Microsoft Project would be worth the investment if we saw a .5% increase in efficiency. That ultimately means .5% less wasted labor hours. It is difficult to project and estimate concrete figures for this cost savings, but considering we are a multibillion dollar company it would be a significant long term savings to all stakeholders.
                
            In conclusion, as stated, Microsoft Project is an important time management and organizational tool that can create efficiencies and directly integrate with other Microsoft products. For Merrill Lynch, I do not believe it is an intelligent or viable option considering we already have a nearly identical custom made tool already in play. Therefore, I do not recommend Microsoft Project for Merrill Lynch.

Thursday, March 7, 2013

Accenture


Underlying Issue

Accenture over the past decade has flourished with the assistance of radical change in their IT infrastructure. Their overall approach and integration of information technology into their business plan has advocated stability and competitiveness. Currently, although a working system is in place, COBIT 5 is being considered to help them stay at the forefront of change. COBIT 5 would allow for better efficiency on all technology platforms, help with business decisions, and streamline information sharing. Ultimately, Accenture has endured growing pain with their current IT system, is the implementation of COBIT 5 worth the investment and the affect it may have in operations across some 50 countries.

Assessment

Accenture’s current IT system which has proven successful has stressed several key principles which include; treat IT like a business within a business rather than a cost, achieve economies of scale through a single vendor, utilize an ERP system to reduce costs, and have managers direct and prioritize objectives.  Each principle served its purpose over the ensuing years and allowed for congruence across all LOB. COBIT 5 is a IT lifestyle that seeks to improve the way Accenture would govern and manage their IT system. Such improvements would include meeting stakeholder needs and uniformity across the entire business while allowing a certain separation between the governing body and management. Ultimately, based upon Accenture’s current management structure we need to decide whether altering our system will help better achieve our objectives. Countless hours and incredible monetary investment has already been made in what we currently use so a transition to COBIT 5 would need to have a measurable increase in efficiency.

Decisions

Basically, at this current junction, Accenture has two choices; maintain its existing IT platform or adapt the COBIT 5 framework. Accenture has enjoyed great success in the current infrastructure and can continue to shape and evolve it to their business. On the other hand, COBIT 5 does offer some advantages but comes at a significant cost. A difficult decision must be made and all options should be considered.
By maintaining Accenture’s existing platform it can continue to tweak and adjust its current model to acquire success. Like the implementation of any new system, growing pains have already been endured and the investment is long past a sunk cost. Accenture has been able to reduce its spending per employee by nearly 60 percent and reduce their overall IT expenses by well over 50 percent. It may be prudent on our part to continue with our IT strategy of reducing unnecessary applications and outsourcing where available to achieve growth in the future.

The alternative approach to our current system would be to adapt the COBIT 5 framework.  COBIT 5 is a system which sets five specific standards across the entire IT infrastructure. These 5 principles although general each have many underlying rules which need to be followed. By implementing this system Accenture would be completely renovating its existing controls, decision methodologies, and overall hierarchy. This approach has proven successful but needs to be carefully analyzed because of its radical changes in the way Accenture would govern its IT system.

The cost associated with COBIT 5 is difficult to determine. The actual software and basic framework principles are available online free. Comprehending and implementing these principles is where the major costs are incurred. The basic reference guide can be purchased through ISACA for $175 which includes the general principles, how to guide for implementation, and cyber security concerns. If additional training is needed, Accenture can send employees to courses which are in the thousand dollar range all depending on the number of employees sent. Another significant investment would be the need for onsite experts or consultants to assist in every day issues. These consultants can be costly and are generally paid well over 100k. Other costs which are difficult to calculate are loss in production and labor spent trying to master the new system. Regardless of associated costs, COBIT 5 if properly implemented and managed does offer many advantages.

Recommendation

COBIT 5 does offer its advantages and with this being said I would recommend any large company who is struggling with their IT systems and infrastructure to adapt this framework. However, I do NOT believe Accenture falls into this category.  We have spent the last decade adapting and learning a system that works for us. We have endured the ups and downs associated with a complete restructuring. Our current platforms have proven successful and we need not take on the risk of a complete renovation. This would hinder our ability to service clients, expand, and remain efficient.


Reflection (3/5)

I have concluded over further examination that the insistence by the consultants in last night’s presentation to refrain from adopting COBIT 5 is excellent advice and should not be taken lightly. Over the past decade or so we have experienced phenomenal growth thanks in part to an IT infrastructure that has proven intuitive to our needs. Specifically our operations in over 50 countries have through trial and error been streamlined because of our MIS framework. But, no such strategy avoids its up and downs. During the course of its first few years of implementation we had to curtail and tweak certain principles towards what we needed as a business. Since then, as described we have been successful, therefore the adoption of a new IT system is unnecessary for a number of reasons.

Last night’s presentation disavowed the adoption of COBIT 5 for three main criteria. The first criteria being the overwhelming monetary investment necessary and labor hours need to adopt a new system. The second reason being the loss in time, investment, and efficiency in not only adopting COBIT 5 but what was lost over the last decade with our existing system. The third and equally important part of the equation is how intricate and overly complicated the system would be to implement. Accenture would need to hire multiple full time COBIT 5 experts to help manage and assist with every day challenges. This not only is a major labor cost, but forces employees to try and interpret new strategies which prevent them for assisting clients.

Ultimately, I must explain that I initially thought the adaption of COBIT 5 would be beneficial to Accenture over the long term. COBIT 5 does offer many advantages over our current system. It would allow for an entirely different governance of our IT infrastructure and is managed through a desire to meet stakeholder needs. COBIT 5 provides an integrated framework to IT covering the enterprise end to end. I personally believe these fundamentals are what make an IT system and conjoining business successful. Yet, we have a working system that does include a framework that has been operationally proven.

In conclusion, if COBIT 5 was a part of the discussion during 2001 when the current system was chosen I may have suggested adopting COBIT 5. But, hindsight is always 20/20 and we have made choices that we must live with. The system currently in place works and should not be adjusted or changed. We are moving down a path of growth and expansion and we should heed what the consultants have advised.

Tuesday, March 5, 2013

Ubuntu - Worth the risk?


Sir,

The Ubuntu operating system, which is gaining some momentum as an alternative to Microsoft office, should be considered during our next management meeting. Ubuntu, although a widely unknown company has been in existence for nearly a decade and does offer some benefits if utilized. As you are fully aware, our particular operations group relies on Microsoft office and its conjoining products heavily. Yet, the OS industry in general is beginning to evolve and an in depth discussion of this subject is necessary on our part to exploit any advantages.

If Merrill Lynch or just our specific group were to implement Ubuntu the first and most obvious reaction to Ubuntu would be its user-friendly interface. It has many of the same controls and icons to that of our current product Windows XP. Ubuntu comes preinstalled on its products and offers an array of useful and production relevant applications. Like Microsoft Office, Ubuntu, offers a full range of software that is nearly identical to MS’s Word, Excel, and Outlook. Considering these three programs are a majority of what we currently use, it may be an effective and financially savvy option.

Now you may ask sir, why it is I am suggesting the implementation of Ubuntu if it does nothing more than what we currently use in Windows? The answer is rather simple and speaks volumes to anyone in a managerial position, MONEY.  There is significant cost-savings if we were to begin integrating Ubuntu.  The basic version of Ubuntu is free and if additional business application were needed we could purchase them for approximately $ 1,050. Although, initially more expensive then Windows, it is a one time fee. The benefit comes from the free updates the Ubuntu automatically conducts to our purchased system. This would prevent us from buying the latest version of Windows/MS on a regular basis. Other cost savings are had when considering this because the latest version on Microsoft Office is quite costly at over $300 per license. If we were to update say only half of our computers, 100 in all we are looking an expense of nearly $30,000.

During the implementation of any system we need to consider the cost of training on any new product. Ubuntu, being extremely similar to Window/MS and user-friendly, would require next to no training. Our group in particular is rather youthful and technologically savvy. It is in my opinion that the transition would be nearly seamless and next to zero loss in production would be had.

In conclusion, the Ubuntu operating system is a nice alternative to Windows XP. Over the course of several years the cost savings could become significant and in our struggling economy any reduction in expenses is helpful. I believe we can make the transition from Windows XP to Ubuntu with minimal loss in production because of our motivated and tech savvy team. Over the course of the next five years, we will see 25% percent of our competitors making the transition, and I don’t see why we can’t be on the forefront of this change.

Thank you for your time and consideration,

Tuesday, February 26, 2013

Zara

Problem/Issue

Currently, the POS infrastructure for ZARA is outdated and putting the company at risk. Xan Salgado Badas and Bruno Sanchez Ocampo are at a turning point of discussion and a decision needs to be made. Salgado Badas believes that their current system needs to be updated to meet their current operational needs while Sanchez adamantly opposes. Although, this may be the case currently, each IT manager has changed his opinion several times. Regardless, the DOS software that is installed is no longer supported by Microsoft. This can eventually lead to issue, but operations currently run with no issue. Yet, the company is at serious risk as new technologies continue to emerge.

Zara is at inherent risk because of the limited capabilities of their current DOS system and how dated the software is. This has become apparent through operations; significant inefficiencies are created through time wasted in the system running and going through tasks. Newer age technology allows employees to maneuver through the system real time to complete tasks such as inventory availability lookup. Therefore, their dated technology will eventually create a competitive advantage for Zara’s competitors and induce loss in profits. An IT solution needs to be implemented in order for all players in Zara’s supply chain to enjoy faster product turnover and strengthen relationships.

Assessment

Zara continues to experience expansion on a domestic level and would like to enjoy growth internationally. Zara’s core competencies depict an organization that gets the latest fashion products to its consumers fast. It currently lacks a large international presence but believes it can be very effective in such markets. Typically, an IT system would be able to track movement of its many products instantaneously, but because of its lack of online sales it has neglected to implement such a system. When a new store is opened little assistance from IT professional is needed. By simply inserting a floppy disk into a terminal drive the new computer has the required applications installed. Next to no maintenance was necessary if basic system error occurred. This is definitely a major advantage. Alternatively, if a serious issue occurred an entirely new software package would need to be installed. Regardless, minimal IT support is needed for new stores and although dated, existing systems can support expansion.

In conclusion, several major questions need to be addressed before a decision can be comfortably made. If a new IT system is implemented how easily can Zara continue with its daily operations with minimal disruptions? Also, will the large monetary investment needed be worth the added and increased functionality? Will the new infrastructure allow Zara to continuous its expansion efforts both domestically and abroad?

Necessary Alternatives

The first and most obvious alternative is to do nothing and leave are current infrastructure in place. Zero initial investment would be incurred and in effect next to no risk would be had from a financial standpoint. Although, in doing nothing there is risk because it creates inefficiencies throughout the company. Our technology would in essence “lag” and our immediate competitors may enjoy a competitive advantage. Our current employees would not need training on new IT platforms, but we would not have tech based efficiency gains.

The second option includes total and complete upgrade to our IT infrastructure which includes our POS terminals. We would utilize Linux, Unix, or Windows as one of our new operating systems. By incorporating a new system we could entirely remove the need for installation through floppy disk because this could be accomplished through the internet. The internet also allows stores to connect to Wi-Fi, which makes it easier to communicate in all areas of the supply chain and execute returns on a much faster basis. Many benefits occur through a new IT system, yet the investment needed is also quite large. Some 15k hours of labor would be needed to convert the system at a rate of approximately 450 euros, this becomes a staggering figure. Training would also be a costly endeavor coming to about 2,000 euros per day per store. Almost a week would be needed at this rate to install the new machines and train employees.  Allow stark the functionality obtained through the update is almost incalculable. Returns become much easy, stock is easier to track and sales information becomes available instantaneously.

Recommendation

Ultimately, although the monetary investment may be large we need to mitigate our IT infrastructure to a new OS system. The added functionality which we could gain over the long term far outweighs initial costs. We would have internet and WI-FI in every store which allows for easier communication. The initial setup of stores would be streamlined and done over the web rather than being reliant on cumbersome floppy disks. Lastly, inventory and returns can be tracked on a much more intelligent level. All of these reasons play major roles in my decision to suggest change. If we continue down are current path we are putting ourselves at risk from competitors and are not taking advantage of technological advances.


Reflection/Review of Presentation (2/27)

Ladies and Gentleman of the board after reviewing yesterday’s presentation, allow well done, several adjustments could have been to make our decision easier. I believe a more in depth analysis of future expansion and the role a new infrastructure plays in this process should have been provided. It would have allowed us to determine whether success in international markets is directly correlated to an updated IT system or not. In addition, it may have been helpful to see actual figures and units of measure associated with each alternative.

The associates utilized an approach that provided a biased position rather than complete oversight of the situation. They tried their best to influence the C-Level managers towards choosing a complete full scale upgrade from existing system to that of Linux operating system. Although, I completely agree with their assumptions I believe it is important to highlight the point that this could hurt the company over the long term. By providing mostly benefits to the upgrade we were partly blind to the advantages associated with our historically successful system.

Although, some improvements could have been made to the presentation, I am confident in suggesting the implementation of new and an up to date IT system. This will provide stability to our expansion and allow us to better monitor our progress. We have achieved great growth, netting nearly 380 million in 2001 and expanding are foothold worldwide to 1,558 locations. Integrating a new IT system will allow us to maintain such expansion and reach even greater heights.

Tuesday, February 19, 2013

1-888-JUNK-VAN's IT Issues


Issue/Underlying Problem

         As Marcus Kingo’s business “1-888-JUNK-VAN grew, he began to encounter issues that would prevent further expansion. His company lacked an IT-system and he desperately needed to introduce a cost effective solution immediately. “1-888-JUNK-VAN” had endured such fast growth that the implementation of an IT-System was crucial because they were currently mishandling information which was preventing them from acquiring new customers. This resulted in stalled market growth, harmed current customer relations, and prevented C-Level managers from focusing on  managerial functions.
         On countless occasions, data clerks and drivers were inputting incorrect or insufficient data into their current IT system which harmed employee morale on many levels. Another significant obstacle was their inability to have multiple working spreadsheets. This made having multiple clerks booking jobs and maintaining accurate accounts almost impossible. What made things worse was the data clerk whom was to upload the day’s final product into the database often uploaded a dated or inaccurate spreadsheet. This left Marcus the daunting task the following day of sorting through and fixing the broken and in turn preventing new jobs from being booked.
          Ultimately, for “1-888-JUNK-VAN”, implementing a cost effective IT infrastructure is absolutely vital. Aspirations of incorporating franchises and capitalizing on large predicted industry growth has left Marcus desperate. The necessary IT tools would make Marcus’s position as CEO easier, and allow him to focus his efforts on expansion rather than fixing pending issues. Having previously lacked any brick and mortar office location, which kept costs low, Marcus Kingo has several options to consider if he wants to keep with growth.

Discussion of Alternatives
          1. One of Marcus’s potential solutions to his IT dilemma is the implementation of Microsoft Access Database. This would be an affordable solution that Kingo could complete by himself over the course of several weeks. The license fee per computer is approximately $179. Additionally, if King deemed it necessary, it could be installed so that it could be remotely accessed. This would require diligent study on Kingo's Part, or require outside consultants to assist. Regardless, by utilizing MS Database there would be no need for a data clerk to upload the spreadsheet at the end of the day and this appears to be the most cost effective solution.

          2. Customized Application is another option which Marcus has considered. This could potentially be an excellent alternative considering the specification included yet several issues may arise. First, by having someone custom build a system, they don’t fully understand the needs of the company and may create something that is not beneficial. Second, the overall cost of such an endeavor may far outweigh the benefits. With a custom system, there would also be a need to hire additional IT professionals to continuously update and maintain the infrastructure.

          3. Another feasible option is that of Google Documents which is low cost and allows for the most flexibility for the end user. Several employees can simultaneously work on the same file and it can be exchanged instantly. Additionally, there are no fees endured from licensing or the purchase of this IT method. This cloud computing option does offer some risk. For starters, if Google Docs stops offering this product all of “1-888-JUNK-VAN’s” files would need to be immediately moved or could be lost for that matter. Another issue that arises is that Google Docs currently does not offer any type of customer support. These fees are difficult to estimate because existing employee IT knowledge is unpredictable.

          4.  Platform as a Service is another interesting yet similar option to that of Google Documents. It is based on a cloud computing model but offers additional flexibility in that users can create their own applications. This alternative is also more of an investment than that of Google Docs costing approximately $300-$600 per month and almost $200 per month in customer service and or application customization. This like Google Docs is a feasible option despite the cost associated with it. Ultimately, Marcus needs to consider whether or not he will be able to handle the IT maintenance required. If the task seems too daunting, additional investment would be necessary to hire IT professionals.

          5.  The fifth and final option being considered today is that of Enterprise Resource Planning System. This alternative provides the most variety in tools offered. With the purchase of the system other business functions are acquired such as purchasing and sales programs. Although helpful, the cost being $2500 per user per year does not make sense for a still relatively small company like “1-888-JUNK-VAN”. Some advantages are that ERP system does allow several users the ability to remotely access files and easily exchange and share information. Ultimately, this system does offer some advantages but with its high costs it may not necessarily be a perfect fit for the company.

Recommendation

          In conclusion, I would recommend “1-888-JUNK-VAN” upgrade from their current IT platform to Google Documents. The implementation of this system will allow for the greatest flexibility, meet the current needs of the company and be the most cost-effective. By using Google Docs, “1-888-JUNK-VAN” employees can work on several documents at once and even remote access files from their homes. This will help Marcus remain true with his company’s initial principals of remaining completely a non-brick and mortar business. Ultimately, by utilizing Google Docs, a large monetary investment is not necessary and the transition between systems should be fairly simple and not require outside help.  To provide further prediction, I believe that if Google Docs does not meet the needs of the company, Marcus can easily adapt another one of the suggested solutions without taking a large financial hit.

Reflection/Review of Presentation (2/20/13)

Ladies and Gentleman of the board after reviewing yesterday's presentation, allow well done, several adjustments could have been made to make our decision easier. First and foremost, I believe a more in depth analysis of each option could have been presented. There appeared to be holes in some of the lines of reasoning which led us to question the effectiveness of such an alternative. Regardless, enough information was given and we were able to confidently move forward with one of the IT solutions. As described, although costly, I believe utilizing a custom application with significant oversight can be the most effective tool for our future success.