Sir,
As you
are aware, Pandora is at a turning point within its business life cycle and
several issues need be to immediately addressed. More specifically the
underlying problem; how does Pandora turn a profit from revenue and how do they
maintain and attract customers? Currently, Pandora’s overall mission is being
swayed by its many venture capitalists each with their own motives. Tim
Westergren started the company with a dream and is trying his best to maintain
it. Unfortunately, management believes that if they continue down this path by
years end there will be zero cash on hand. Several core issues plague Pandora
but with precise action we believe we can eradicate any long lasting negative
effects.
To
begin, we believe Pandora does not have the personnel needed to manage and
guide a company in the media industry. We have found that in general they lack
the professional experience needed and in turn this hinders their ability to
properly manage. Tim Westergren acknowledges this predicament and even suggests
that he was not properly qualified nor had a desire to guide Pandora and become
the CEO. Unfortunately, this was a
common thread throughout many of the leadership roles. Individuals lacked
experience or in general weren’t happy and didn’t feel comfortable with their
job descriptions. Secondly, Pandora was not meeting customer demands and lacked
integral advertising to attract and maintain customer base. Other listening
mediums had perfected this area and Pandora was losing market share to power
hungry competitors. Business’s in general enjoy growth and thrive through the
addition of new clients in part from a strategic marketing plan.
Another conjoining issue or desire was to be
the most effective company at helping consumers find the music they were
looking for. Joe Kennedy, recently hired
CEO (2004) recognizes this problem and attempts to address it with direct to
consumer internet radio service. This
gave birth to Pandora Radio which contributed to a successful future.
Regardless, meeting the needs of their consumers through desired music genres
was paramount. Moving forward, several issues plagued Pandora and we as
consultants in the ensuing paragraphs plan to provide a series of effective
alternatives and solutions.
In an attempt to establish a loyal
and continuously growing customer base, Pandora needs to establish some
guidelines in how they will advertise and market to new consumers. This will
play a crucial role in future probability and expand market share. In 2007,
revenues were approximately .69 cents per hour per listener. This is a
competitive rate if they are able to maintain current users, but since no money
was being spent on advertising, margins became stagnant and effected growth.
Through a established marketing strategy Pandora should be able to
differentiate themselves, continue to provide a free services, and attract new
customers with additional media platforms such as cell phones and tablets.
Several different options surface
when discussing the main issues surrounding Pandora’s future. The first option
is do nothing and proceed as if no problems need to be addressed. This
typically is the most attractive alternative, because no investment cost is
necessary and there is no loss in production from adhering to new missions or
infrastructure. In contrast, Pandora doing nothing will continue to see only
moderate profits and sorely under achieve growth in customer base. Our analysis concludes that this option
should not be pursued.
The second alternative is to
transition to a premium subscription based model. This option fuels profits and
creates a better product for the end user. It is a strictly ad free model that
provided a reasonable cost structure establishes a loyal customer base through
new features such as better song selection and as mentioned no ads. We feel
that existing users who utilize the free option should continue to enjoy our
product, but will be capped and restricted on a monthly basis to a certain predetermined
threshold. In contrast, having to pay for our service may deter some users and
push them to our competitors which still offer it for free.
The third option involves a
combination of a subscription ad free based model and the current
infrastructure flushed with additional advertisements. No real value is added
to the end consumer in terms of the product, meaning no new perks or options
are provided. Yet, the service remaining free is an enticing avenue AND more
revenue is generated through advertising from companies who want their brand to
receive more exposure. It allows advertisers to specifically target certain
demographics which can lead to commission fees if users make purchases on
linked websites. In addition, the amount of ads can be reduced if users answer
questions about music preferences. We believe this is the most attractive of
alternatives because it generates more revenue for you (Pandora) and keeps the
service free.
Ultimately, upon further analysis
of the three presented options, I believe that option three should be pursued.
As described this alternative involves utilizing a subscription ad free model
and the current free service with additional ads. In turn this will help
maintain current customer base, create new revenues, and attract and obtain new
market share. Attempting to achieve economies of scales and remaining true with
Westergren’s dreams will create the most value for its shareholders and is
least detrimental to everyday operations. By establishing a new strategy and
employing personnel with the proper experience Pandora can continue to better
their service and remain competitive.
Some other key ingredients to
Pandora’s success will be to remain differentiated and adapt to a changing
environment and embracing new technologies. Focusing on client needs by
offering premier services will allow an atmosphere where a consumer’s view of
advertisements is merely an afterthought because they are receiving an
unbelievable product. By achieving economies of scale solid profits can be
received which keeps investors satisfied with new missions and directions of
the business. In conclusion, it is logical to suggest that in a service type
business, advertising and market is crucial but maintaining and nurturing client
desires and image is second to none.
Reflection
Sir,
I hope this message finds you well. As per our
discussion/presentation yesterday regarding Pandora and its future I would like
to bring forth several conclusions to assist in your decision. Upon further analysis,
I believe what our consultants have suggested makes sense and should be pursued
based upon our business position. Remaining within the parameters of our goals
and business strategies it would be prudent on our part to at least consider
their recommendations. Below I’ll recap what was discussed and highlight the
important details.
As suggested, remaining differentiated by offering and
maintaining a free service utilizing targeted marketing is above all else
vital. In addition to this free service, offering a subscription service that
is ad-free is enticing and does meet the needs of a specific demographic. With
this two-tiered approach being pursued, Pandora can begin the realignment of
its mission of focusing on scale and attracting new customers through new technologies.
The above listed strategies are the overall direction in
which the consultants and I believe Pandora should move. In order to achieve
these missions, the consultants recommended several actions each with a
specific purpose. Introducing and providing a Mobile Application offered both
on Apple and Android products allows us to attract new customers and bring in
additional revenue. This in the eyes of the consultants is cutting/leading edge
technology, which any good development team will create in the near future.
Restructuring our budget to focus on the production and updating of this mobile
application should be initiated and other frivolous spending should be reduced.
In addition to our new focus on technologies, adapting a
two-tiered approach which incorporates subscription based offerings will lead
to greater revenues. This should be immediately adapted because as discussed
profit margins at year end will fall short of expectations. Regardless of the subscription
or offering that a customer chooses, it had been suggested that Pandora include
some audio advertising for additional revenue. This can be as small as a 15
second clip, or as in depth as an interactive game or advertisement. Of course,
consumers who opt for the premier subscription package will avoid this all
together.
As you have witnessed, the consultants did an excellent job
of dissecting the many issues that concern Pandora. There recommended action
should not be taken lightly and we should immediately implement these ideas
where we can and budget accordingly.
Thank you for your time and consideration and please contact
me with any further issues.