Underlying Issue
Accenture over the past decade has flourished with the
assistance of radical change in their IT infrastructure. Their overall approach
and integration of information technology into their business plan has
advocated stability and competitiveness. Currently, although a working system
is in place, COBIT 5 is being considered to help them stay at the forefront of
change. COBIT 5 would allow for better efficiency on all technology platforms,
help with business decisions, and streamline information sharing. Ultimately,
Accenture has endured growing pain with their current IT system, is the
implementation of COBIT 5 worth the investment and the affect it may have in
operations across some 50 countries.
Assessment
Accenture’s current IT system which has proven successful
has stressed several key principles which include; treat IT like a business
within a business rather than a cost, achieve economies of scale through a
single vendor, utilize an ERP system to reduce costs, and have managers direct
and prioritize objectives. Each
principle served its purpose over the ensuing years and allowed for congruence
across all LOB. COBIT 5 is a IT lifestyle that seeks to improve the way
Accenture would govern and manage their IT system. Such improvements would
include meeting stakeholder needs and uniformity across the entire business
while allowing a certain separation between the governing body and management.
Ultimately, based upon Accenture’s current management structure we need to
decide whether altering our system will help better achieve our objectives.
Countless hours and incredible monetary investment has already been made in
what we currently use so a transition to COBIT 5 would need to have a
measurable increase in efficiency.
Decisions
Basically, at this current junction, Accenture has two
choices; maintain its existing IT platform or adapt the COBIT 5 framework.
Accenture has enjoyed great success in the current infrastructure and can
continue to shape and evolve it to their business. On the other hand, COBIT 5
does offer some advantages but comes at a significant cost. A difficult
decision must be made and all options should be considered.
By maintaining Accenture’s existing platform it can continue
to tweak and adjust its current model to acquire success. Like the implementation
of any new system, growing pains have already been endured and the investment
is long past a sunk cost. Accenture has been able to reduce its spending per
employee by nearly 60 percent and reduce their overall IT expenses by well over
50 percent. It may be prudent on our part to continue with our IT strategy of
reducing unnecessary applications and outsourcing where available to achieve
growth in the future.
The alternative approach to our current system would be to
adapt the COBIT 5 framework. COBIT 5 is
a system which sets five specific standards across the entire IT
infrastructure. These 5 principles although general each have many underlying
rules which need to be followed. By implementing this system Accenture would be
completely renovating its existing controls, decision methodologies, and
overall hierarchy. This approach has proven successful but needs to be
carefully analyzed because of its radical changes in the way Accenture would
govern its IT system.
The cost associated with COBIT 5 is difficult to determine.
The actual software and basic framework principles are available online free.
Comprehending and implementing these principles is where the major costs are
incurred. The basic reference guide can be purchased through ISACA for $175
which includes the general principles, how to guide for implementation, and
cyber security concerns. If additional training is needed, Accenture can send
employees to courses which are in the thousand dollar range all depending on
the number of employees sent. Another significant investment would be the need
for onsite experts or consultants to assist in every day issues. These
consultants can be costly and are generally paid well over 100k. Other costs
which are difficult to calculate are loss in production and labor spent trying
to master the new system. Regardless of associated costs, COBIT 5 if properly
implemented and managed does offer many advantages.
Recommendation
COBIT 5 does offer its advantages and with this being said I
would recommend any large company who is struggling with their IT systems and
infrastructure to adapt this framework. However, I do NOT believe Accenture
falls into this category. We have spent
the last decade adapting and learning a system that works for us. We have
endured the ups and downs associated with a complete restructuring. Our current
platforms have proven successful and we need not take on the risk of a complete
renovation. This would hinder our ability to service clients, expand, and
remain efficient.
Reflection (3/5)
I have concluded over further examination that the
insistence by the consultants in last night’s presentation to refrain from
adopting COBIT 5 is excellent advice and should not be taken lightly. Over the
past decade or so we have experienced phenomenal growth thanks in part to an IT
infrastructure that has proven intuitive to our needs. Specifically our
operations in over 50 countries have through trial and error been streamlined because
of our MIS framework. But, no such strategy avoids its up and downs. During the
course of its first few years of implementation we had to curtail and tweak
certain principles towards what we needed as a business. Since then, as
described we have been successful, therefore the adoption of a new IT system is
unnecessary for a number of reasons.
Last night’s presentation disavowed the adoption of COBIT 5
for three main criteria. The first criteria being the overwhelming monetary investment
necessary and labor hours need to adopt a new system. The second reason being
the loss in time, investment, and efficiency in not only adopting COBIT 5 but
what was lost over the last decade with our existing system. The third and
equally important part of the equation is how intricate and overly complicated
the system would be to implement. Accenture would need to hire multiple full
time COBIT 5 experts to help manage and assist with every day challenges. This
not only is a major labor cost, but forces employees to try and interpret new
strategies which prevent them for assisting clients.
Ultimately, I must explain that I initially thought the
adaption of COBIT 5 would be beneficial to Accenture over the long term. COBIT
5 does offer many advantages over our current system. It would allow for an
entirely different governance of our IT infrastructure and is managed through a
desire to meet stakeholder needs. COBIT 5 provides an integrated framework to
IT covering the enterprise end to end. I personally believe these fundamentals
are what make an IT system and conjoining business successful. Yet, we have a
working system that does include a framework that has been operationally
proven.
In conclusion, if COBIT 5 was a part of the discussion
during 2001 when the current system was chosen I may have suggested adopting
COBIT 5. But, hindsight is always 20/20 and we have made choices that we must
live with. The system currently in place works and should not be adjusted or
changed. We are moving down a path of growth and expansion and we should heed
what the consultants have advised.
No comments:
Post a Comment